blaze media

Homer Simpson would be proud of this defense

Five of the seven suspects in the now-infamous Cincinnati beatdown case appeared in court Thursday for arraignments and bail hearings. It was a routine appearance — until one defense attorney made what may be the most unintentionally revealing courtroom statement of the year. Maybe even the decade.

“Vernon’s attorney, Clyde Bennett, argued that the case against his client had been inflamed due to race and politics, but in reality it was just a fight fueled by alcohol.”

The sooner we remind people that they are moral agents — capable of making choices and accountable for them — the sooner we’ll see fewer ‘Cincinnati beatdowns’ in the news.

Let that sink in for a moment. According to Bennett, it would be unfair to frame the case as racial or political. No — don’t get it twisted — it was just about drunken violence. Ah, yes, much better.

The irony is thick enough to spread on toast.

For two decades, Americans have been told everything is about race and politics. We’ve lived under a constant drumbeat of racialized news coverage. We don’t have to reach back to Trayvon Martin or Michael Brown — George Floyd in 2020 will do. Cities burned for months while the national media insisted the destruction was “mostly peaceful.”

Back then, pointing out the deadly fentanyl in Floyd’s system, the crime he’d just committed, or broader issues like high crime rates in certain neighborhoods or the role of fatherlessness in cycles of violence was “racist.” Facts didn’t matter. Only the race narrative did.

Sick of the double standard

The narrative claimed that violence disproportionately involved black men, which supposedly proved “systemic racism.” Why? Because in the Marxist worldview, crime stems from the environment — people are violent because the “system” forces them to be. If you took the same statistics and said, “Yes, something is going wrong with crime, violence, and broken families — let’s talk about it,” you were branded a racist.

It’s always been a one-way street. Race gets invoked when it advances a left-wing narrative of grievance and dependency. When it doesn’t fit, race suddenly disappears from the discussion and you’re told to drop the subject.

Americans are sick of this double standard. Racism is wrong for everyone.

The statistics show something is deeply wrong, and ignoring it won’t fix anything. But the left’s “solutions” aren’t solutions — they’re programs to stoke grievance, increase dependency, and keep personal responsibility out of the conversation. It is always someone else’s fault, and that fault is usually “whiteness.”

Which brings us back to Thursday’s courtroom gem. Bennett’s “blame it on the alcohol” defense isn’t just legally flimsy — it’s philosophically bankrupt. Being drunk while committing a crime is not a defense. You can’t rob a store, beat someone up, or kill a man and then shrug because you had one too many.

That’s not how the law works. That’s not how life works.

Choices have consequences

The bigger problem is that this mindset — “I had no choice, the system made me do it, those people made me do it, the booze made me do it” — has become the default for too many Americans. It strips people of agency and moral responsibility. It says, “I don’t make choices. Things just happen to me.” That’s a recipe for failure.

We need to bring back the idea that character matters. If someone can control his anger and walk away from a fight, that shows good character. If he can’t, we don’t help him by letting him blame booze, “the system,” or “the man.”

At some point, everyone needs to learn that choices have consequences.

We’ve gone from laughing at “blame it on the alcohol” to taking it seriously as social theory. That’s not progress. It’s regression — into a world where no one is accountable for anything. In this world, you can declare yourself a victim and opt out of morality.

RELATED: The awful irony of the White House’s crackdown on juvenile crime

Mikhail Rudenko via iStock/Getty Images

The incentive to claim oppression is huge. If you’re white, the easiest way is to identify as an “oppressed” sexual minority. This isn’t just about sex — it’s about securing a lifetime exemption from blame.

The Cincinnati case is ugly. And yet a defense attorney stood in court and suggested that drunken mob violence is better than racial politics. That’s how far we’ve drifted from personal responsibility.

If we want to cut crime and restore order, we must stop rewarding this thinking. We must revive the idea that personal responsibility isn’t outdated. We must stop letting people hide behind whatever excuse is in fashion — race, politics, poverty, wealth, or booze.

Thirty years ago, “I wasn’t asleep; I was drunk!” was a Homer Simpson joke. Today, it could be a legitimate legal defense in certain left-wing circles.

The sooner we remind people that they are moral agents — capable of making choices and accountable for them — the sooner we’ll see fewer “Cincinnati beatdowns” in the news. Until then, leftists, having injected race into every conversation, should take responsibility for what they created.

​Opinion & analysis, Crime, Cincinnati, Cincinnati beatdown, Race, Black on white crime, Racism, Black lives matter, Defense, Drunk, George floyd, Marxism, Systemic racism, Police, Homer simpson 

blaze media

Trump and the left join forces to herd Democrats into a 2028 disaster

Democratic presidential hopefuls might be wise to keep their heads down and their mouths shut. Whenever one voices an opinion that aligns with the broad American mainstream, his own base punishes him for it. Meanwhile, President Donald Trump keeps laying political traps to ensure that those intraparty attacks continue.

The latest target is former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg. During an episode of “Pod Save America,” co-host Jon Favreau pressed him on a Senate vote to halt weapons shipments to Israel and on how future U.S. administrations should handle relations with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

On each and every issue, Trump has stood by the water and tried to lead Democrats toward the desert.

Buttigieg, who for some reason is a potential 2028 contender despite his disastrous stint in Washington, answered as carefully and politically as he could, addressing the horrors of war, saying American munitions cannot be used in offenses “that shock the conscience,” adding that we “see images every day” from Israel that hit this mark.

He also said he would be a lot harder on Netanyahu than Trump, but expressed American friendship for Israel and emphasized correction over isolation.

All in all, pretty standard. But in an age when the loudest Democrat activists demand total condemnation and isolation of Israel, it sure didn’t satisfy.

“I respect Pete. But we need moral clarity, not status quo,” Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.), another potential 2028 contender, posted on X, adding that Democrats should have voted in unison to block weapons to Israel and should also join his own letter recognizing a Palestinian state.

“Pete is a smart guy and I admire a lot of what he’s done,” former Obama deputy national security adviser Ben Rhodes posted, “but I have absolutely no idea what he thinks based on these answers. Just tell us what you believe.”

Barack Obama, for whom Rhodes worked and Favreau wrote, was a master of political pieties that conveyed little substance. But the Democratic Party has shifted dramatically since he left office in 2017.

“For somebody who’s criticizing what was done wrong by Joe Biden and everyone else … it’s interesting that he can’t just answer the question of the most pressing issue,” Lindsey Granger, co-host of The Hill’s “Rising,” said.

“I don’t think we’re in a space where Americans are accepting ambiguity in the way that they might have [before].”

By Wednesday, Buttigieg was backtracking. Speaking to Politico, he offered the cringey explanation: “It’s important to be clear about something this enormous and this painful. It’s just that it’s so enormous and it’s so painful that sometimes words can fail.”

He then proceeded to repent of any trace of nuance, pledging to support a weapons embargo on Israel, saying he’d recognize a Palestinian state, and coming out against another 10-year security agreement with Israel.

But some ambiguity on a complicated question with a traditional ally is pretty standard fare for foreign policy. The reality is that the loudest Democrats in the room simply aren’t accepting support for Israel from their leaders. It’s all reminiscent of their 2020 presidential primaries, when all candidates except then-former Vice President Joe Biden said they would decriminalize illegally entering the country. Peer pressure is a hell of a thing.

And all that flak was just from the blue corner. In the red corner, Trump’s been busily and happily pushing Democratic politicians to take the minority stance on every 7-3 issue he can think of, from illegal immigration and MS-13 to lower taxes and foreign aid, all the way up to men in women’s sports.

On every issue, Trump has stood by the water and tried to lead Democrats toward the desert. When party leaders and consultants were finally able to get their members to stop defending the foreign gangbangers Trump is deporting, he dropped “Alligator Alcatraz” on them, triggering a whole new round of public hyperventilating.

This week’s edition was violent street crime and homeless drug addicts, which any honest D.C. resident will admit are both major problems, particularly over the past six years of hard-left Democrat city council leadership. Trump’s use of federal police and National Guardsmen, as well as his temporary takeover of the Metropolitan Police Department, to clear out tent encampments and arrest gangbangers has incited the heck out of the city’s wealthy white liberal population, but reaction is a lot more mixed among the poor black population that suffers from street crime the most.

The reality is that the American people are a lot more hawkish on crime than the Democrat base. Before the D.C. intervention, polling showed Trump at +1 for how he handles crime. That same polling had President Joe Biden’s crime handling at -26. Yet as I write, two Democrat congressmen are filming themselves in front of Guard vehicles at Union Station. They cannot help themselves. Their base is hungry and must be fed.

It’s 2020 all over again, except this time the Democrat machine is far too weak to foist an enfeebled alternative candidate onto the voters. “Biden me once, shame on you; Biden me twice …”

Democrats can’t find their footing, their base is refusing to let them move to solid ground, and every week or two the president is shaking the ground beneath them.

They should balance very carefully. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) can say “no f**king way” to money to fund crackdowns on illegal gun violence and public drug use all day, but voters aren’t buying it.

Blaze News: Trump’s DC crime crackdown sparks Democrats’ denial

Fox News: Chris Matthews says Democrats ‘falling into a trap of defending what’s indefensible’ on crime

The New York Post: ‘Morning Joe’ reveals DC journalist privately shared concerns about crime while publicly denouncing Trump’s plan

Blaze News: Democrats suffer ugly meltdown over promise of safety in DC — but city dwellers are optimistic

Glenn Beck: The capital of the free world cannot be lawless

Delano Squires: DC’s crime problem is much worse than you think

Blaze News: Liberal media’s crazy responses to Trump activating the DC National Guard

Blaze News: Deranged DC leftist faces consequences for allegedly hurling a Subway footlong at a federal officer

Blaze News: Liberal DOJ employee charged with felony, fired for allegedly hurling a Subway footlong at a federal officer

Sign up for Bedford’s newsletter
Sign up to get Blaze Media senior politics editor Christopher Bedford’s newsletter.

​Opinion & analysis, Politics 

blaze media

All-natural tallow: Everything your skin needs — without the hormone disruptors

During the pandemic, there was a large spike in the number of girls entering puberty at a very young age, a recent study from Italy showed.

“Precocious puberty,” as the condition is known, is defined as the development of secondary sexual characteristics — breasts, pubic hair, larger testicles, a deeper voice, etc. — before the age of 8 in girls and 9 in boys.

Tallow balms are easy to make at home — I make one with tallow, olive oil, and rosemary from my garden.

Entering puberty that early can lead to significant complications. As well as being associated with reduced stature and other physical problems, studies have found links with emotional and behavioral issues including substance abuse, social isolation, truancy, and sexual promiscuity.

Growing up too fast

It’s generally reckoned that girls suffer from precocious puberty at a much higher rate than boys: something like 0.2% as opposed to 0.05%, although there may be quite wide national variation. It’s not known why girls suffer at such a higher rate, but there could be a deep survival mechanism at work — perhaps one that allows girls to mature faster and reproduce earlier under particular conditions (war, scarcity, extreme stress).

The researchers behind the study looked at data for 133 diagnosed cases of precocious puberty in Italian girls between January 2016 and June 2021. While they found 72 diagnosed cases in the four years before the beginning of the pandemic, they found 61 cases between March 2020 and June 2021, a rate of four new cases a month. That’s about three times the rate before the pandemic.

The average age of sexual development has been getting lower and lower for decades across the West — maybe by as much as three months per decade for girls since the 1970s — but clearly, the number of cases observed during the pandemic was way outside that general trend.

Fat and unhappy

So what was going on?

The researchers found a clear link between the increase in cases and weight gain, which is a known risk factor for precocious puberty. Fatter children are more likely to enter puberty sooner.

The pandemic was a disaster for children’s health all round. Trapped inside, away from their friends for months at a time, bombarded with terrifying propaganda, left with nothing to do but watch TV or play video games or scroll TikTok while their parents answered Zoom calls in the next room, children got fatter — a lot fatter. Obesity rates went through the roof, and so did rates of mental health problems: anxiety, depression, suicidality.

All that blue light from screens probably didn’t help either. Rat studies have shown that chronic blue-light exposure can bring forward puberty, believe it or not, because of changes to patterns of hormone release.

Sanitizer insanity

Another factor, the researchers think — and you may find this surprising — was the “increased use of hand and surface sanitizers.”

Remember how much people were sanitizing their hands and even home deliveries? In many cases, especially out in public, people were cleaning their hands after every social interaction and every time they walked in and out of a room.

I made a point of never using the hand sanitizers on offer, because I know they contain big doses of endocrine-disrupting chemicals, chemicals that interfere with the body’s natural hormone balance and can have all sorts of unpleasant effects, from reducing testosterone levels to interfering with sexual development in the womb or during puberty.

It’s an unfortunate truth that the young are especially vulnerable to these chemicals, and if they interfere in processes that can only happen once — like sexual differentiation in the womb, “mini-puberty” in early childhood, or “big” puberty in adolescence — the effects can be irreversible. Not good.

A very nasty chemical

One such chemical commonly found in hand sanitizers is triclosan. Triclosan is a very nasty chemical, not least of all because it can dramatically increase the absorption of other endocrine-disrupting chemicals like BPA.

So if you coat your hands with triclosan-laden sanitizer and then touch, say, a plastic toy or a piece of thermal paper, you’ll get a mega dose of harmful chemicals, right into your blood.

It’s not just hand sanitizer, though. Pretty much all modern personal care products contain endocrine disruptors, and for this reason they represent one of our most persistent sources of exposure to harmful chemicals. Research has shown that women are at particular risk, because they use so many personal care products. One study claims college-age women in the U.S. use an average of eight personal care products a day that contain known endocrine-disrupting chemicals. Some women in the study were using as many as 17 a day!

RELATED: Blaze News investigates: BPA is no longer the stuff of baby bottles, but it still might be a big problem

Photo by Rich Sugg/Kansas City Star/Tribune News Service via Getty Image

Cold turkey

The simplest way to reduce your exposure to these harmful chemicals is to stop using products that contain them. Research shows that if women go cold-turkey on their favorite personal care products, levels of harmful phthalates, parabens, and phenols in their urine decrease by as much as 45% in just three days.

Of course, you still need to keep yourself spic and span, but giving up chemical-heavy supermarket soaps and scrubs doesn’t mean you can’t wash, thankfully. A lot of products can be replaced with tallow-based alternatives.

Fat of the land

Tallow is rendered animal fat, usually beef fat. If that sounds disgusting to you, it shouldn’t. That’s how soap used to be made, using natural rather than artificial fats, and as with so many things, the old ways are better.

Being animal fat, tallow has a chemical profile that’s very similar to human fat and contains various natural substances, including vitamins and cholesterol, that are nourishing for the skin. Modern soaps tend to strip the skin of moisture and nutrients and dry it out. They also destroy the colonies of beneficial micro-organisms that live on our skin and protect us, acting as a first line of defense against harmful pathogens entering the body.

A personal favorite

You don’t have to smell like beef, either, unless you want to. Tallow products can be fragranced with natural substances like rosemary oil or lavender.

Tallow balms are easy to make at home — I make one with tallow, olive oil, and rosemary from my garden — but there’s a growing number of companies that make high-quality tallow products as well.

My favorite is North Idaho Tallow Company. The company’s tallow sugar scrub — a mixture of tallow and cane sugar, with natural fragrance — is just the ticket after a heavy workout, when you need to wash away the sweat and effort and come up looking sparkling. As well as offering soaps, balms, lip balms, and beard care products, the company also sells tallow-and-beeswax candles, which are so much better than paraffin ones.

Visit idahotallow.com.

​Maha, Skincare, Lifestyle, Bpa, Endocrine disruptors, Health, Women’s health, Makeup, Soap, Provisions 

blaze media

MAGA meets the machine: Trump goes all in on AI

The technology once confined to science fiction has now become reality, and its impact will be revolutionary. When artificial intelligence first broke through, many MAGA supporters reacted with suspicion. They saw it as another weapon for woke elites — a way to erase inconvenient facts and reshape public opinion, potentially with government support.

President Donald Trump acted to block that threat. His recent executive order directs the federal government to contract only with AI companies that “prioritize truthfulness and ideological neutrality.”

A MAGA-aligned council of AI policy experts will make the next golden age of American exceptionalism possible.

That’s a strong start, but MAGA weakens itself if it treats AI solely as a threat. I learned that firsthand, working in the field before most people even knew what AI was. It’s coming whether we like it or not.

Meanwhile, other nations — including enemies such as China — have committed to developing AI. If they reach artificial superintelligence first, the consequences could be catastrophic. Our technologists understand the stakes. America must lead in this arena, not trail behind.

Winning over MAGA

Despite what’s at stake, MAGA has a dearth of people who support or even understand AI — at least, until recently, when President Trump delivered remarks at the “Winning the AI Race” summit hosted by the “All-In” podcast at the Hill and Valley Forum.

That change is monumental. Imagine a few years ago, when an AI bot put you in TikTok prison for violating the site’s “terms of service” — as I was — and someone told you that a re-elected Donald Trump would participate in an AI summit with the big Silicon Valley companies and MAGA-aligned leaders.

That’s why people like James Burnham are key to bridging the gap between the Silicon Valley and the MAGA base.

Burnham bridging the gap

At the summit, I met with Burnham, a former senior lawyer at the Department of Government Efficiency and now head of the AI Innovation Council, to talk about MAGA’s role in shaping the future of artificial intelligence.

He may share the name of the author of “Suicide of the West” — a man often called the intellectual godfather of neoreaction and one of the first practitioners of psychological warfare — but the resemblance ends there. This Burnham is an unapologetic optimist, a happy warrior, and an original MAGA activist determined to unite the movement’s best minds with the tech right.

His goal: Mend fences and help define AI policy for the years ahead.

“I was there when Trump went down the golden escalator,” Burnham told me. “My hope is that I can help bridge the gap between true MAGA and the tech right.”

Some might see him as an unlikely figure for the role, given that his enthusiasm for AI matches that of Silicon Valley’s most bullish innovators. But for Burnham, advancing American AI is more than a defensive measure against hostile nations. It’s an opportunity to create America’s next golden age.

As he told the New York Post: “Artificial intelligence is a revolutionary technology with the potential to make the United States wealthier and greater than it has ever been.”

The AI we deserve

Burnham’s perspective is not exactly shared by much of MAGA — and understandably so. After all, as recently as last year, we were terrified that woke tech companies would use AI to clamp down on our speech. Having had that experience, our instinct might be to try to kill the technology in its crib.

RELATED: The AI takeover isn’t coming — it’s already here

sankai via iStock/Getty Images

But that’s simply not realistic — and not just because China will develop AI without us. The Silicon Valley’s left will then seize the mantle of the future. We can’t allow that to happen, not least of all because the left doesn’t deserve that kind of credit. All leftists want out of AI is the world’s smartest and most vigilant woke hall monitor.

America can — and must — do better than that.

But if we’re going to do better, we need the tech world to be willing to talk to us. That’s why people like Burnham are so critical. You win more flies with honey than with vinegar — just ask AIs themselves.

Unlike AI, however, a MAGA-aligned council of AI policy experts won’t just flatter the people it engages with. It will make the next golden age of American exceptionalism possible.

​Opinion & analysis, Artificial intelligence, Donald trump, Ai, Executive order, Neutrality, Ideology, Leftism, Conservatism, Maga, America first, Big tech, Censorship, Tiktok, China, Silicon valley, Winning the ai race, James burnham, Suicide of the west, Department of government efficiency, Doge, Innovation 

blaze media

NFL platforms ‘child-friendly’ drag queen cheerleaders

The NFL is pushing hard for male cheerleaders, with 12 of the teams featuring a DEI cheer lineup this season.

The Baltimore Ravens will have 19 male cheerleaders on their squad.

While fans are not happy, some claim that there have always been male cheerleaders — but there is a major difference between the male cheerleaders of the past and present.

“There are certain teams I saw this with the Rams when I had season tickets in the early ’90s. They were at Anaheim Stadium. There were the regular Ram cheerleaders that wore the regular, skimpy suits, kind of looked like they were doing gymnastics,” BlazeTV contributor Steve Kim says on “Fearless with Jason Whitlock.”

“And there’s also a cheer squad, which they had, they were much more innocent, right? And those groups had big muscular guys because someone had to lift the girls and catch them as they’re doing the flips,” he continues.

“They were not acting or dressed like they were feminine. Like, you could tell those guys were in good shape. … When you’re acting very feminine and sexualizing it, I think that’s the issue that certain people are having,” he adds.

BlazeTV contributor and former NFL wide receiver TJ Moe jokes that he is “one of those people.”

“Look, this is very flamboyant. It’s very gay. It’s openly, obviously, both of those things. There’s no argument against that. Anybody who has a pair of eyes would tell you that. It’s the logical extension of, you know, the first openly trans cheerleader with Carolina that happened a few years ago,” Moe says.

BlazeTV host Jason Whitlock agrees with both Kim and Moe and isn’t surprised by the NFL’s move to force male cheerleaders down fans’ throats.

“The NFL, I have low expectations for it. It bothers me that they’re going along with this. All this is a softer, more effective, child-friendly drag show. That’s all this is. It’s more effective,” Whitlock says.

“Your 8-year-old son says, ‘Daddy who’s this gym guy, and why is he dressed like a girl, what’s going on here?’ … it just sparks conversations and puts thoughts in kids’ heads,” he adds.

Want more from Jason Whitlock?

To enjoy more fearless conversations at the crossroads of culture, faith, sports, and comedy with Jason Whitlock, subscribe to BlazeTV — the largest multi-platform network of voices who love America, defend the Constitution, and live the American dream.

​Video phone, Camera phone, Upload, Free, Video, Sharing, Youtube.com, Fearless with jason whitlock, Jason whitlock, The blaze, Blazetv, Blaze news, Blaze podcasts, Blaze podcast network, Blaze media, Blaze online, Blaze originals, Nfl cheerleaders, Baltimore ravens, Minnesota vikings, Trans cheerleaders, Dei cheerleaders 

blaze media

Louisiana man who intentionally dragged officer for 500 feet with his truck is charged with murder after officer dies

A Louisiana police officer who was dragged for 500 feet from a truck died of his injuries, and the man accused of intentionally striking him is now charged with murder.

Gad Black, 41, bragged on social media about hitting Sgt. Caleb Eisworth with his Ford F-150 truck in June, according to prosecutors. Eisworth was hospitalized with very serious injuries, as previously reported by Blaze Media, but he died on Sunday.

‘Check Him Out on Joor Rd. Stretched One.’

Black appeared in court Monday and was relatively calm when officials upgraded his charges to include murder. He is also facing hate-crime charges.

Eisworth was driving home on his police motorcycle when he was struck by Black near Greenwell Springs Road and Joor Road at about 11 a.m., according to prosecutors.

“Check Him Out on Joor Rd. Stretched One,” Black allegedly wrote on Facebook.

He appeared in court virtually before Commissioner Nicole Robinson.

Black’s family released a statement offering condolences to the family of the officer, who was a 23-year veteran of the force.

“On behalf of the Black family, we extend our deepest condolences to the family of Sergeant Caleb Eisworth. We are heartbroken to learn of his passing, and our prayers are with his loved ones during this difficult time.”

RELATED: Parents of 11-year-old targeted in murder plot by 5th-graders break their silence: ‘There was a mastermind’

Black’s sanity hearing is scheduled for Sept. 3 before Judge Donald Johnson.

“The sanity issue has been raised, not sure if the commission has been selected or picked, but I anticipate that one will be,” District Attorney Hillar Moore said. “That will determine his mental condition at the time of the offense and currently to assist counsel.”

East Baton Rouge Sheriff Sid Gautreaux condemned the suspect after his arrest in June.

“This was a deliberate and cowardly attack on an officer — one of our community’s protectors — and it strikes at the very heart of public safety,” Gautreaux said in part.

Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up here!

​Gad black murder, Man drags cop for 500 ft, Louisiana crime, Sgt caleb eisworth, Crime 

blaze media

Trump’s tariffs won’t stop India’s tech takeover

President Donald Trump blasted India with 50% tariffs, which are set to take effect August 27. These tariffs reflect Trump’s instinct that India is becoming the next China — and he’s spot-on.

Unfortunately, the tariffs will do little to stop this. Why? Because India isn’t coming for our manufacturing. They’re coming for our technology sector — and they’ve been remarkably successful both at scooping up jobs and flying under the radar.

Bangalore is booming. Boston is becoming a bust. What’s going on?

Since 2001, America has lost roughly 5 million jobs to China. During the same period, America lost up to 4 million technology jobs to India. Moreover, India now has access to sensitive American technology and information.

This is beyond an economic issue; it’s a silent national emergency.

If we are serious about reshoring American industry, then tariffs on Indian products won’t cut it. We should also tariff Indian services.

Made in Mumbai

India’s technology industry is bustling. In 2024, technology made up approximately 7% of India’s GDP. The industry employs 5.4 million people and added 126,000 new jobs last year alone. Revenue was up 5.1% year over year.

Technology is transforming India. Cities like Bangalore boast newly minted billionaires and skyscrapers. Meanwhile, technology employment in many major American cities, like Boston, is stagnating.

Bangalore is booming. Boston is becoming a bust. What’s going on?

One word: offshoring.

Increasingly, American companies are moving their production of digital services to India. Why? Because Indian labor is cheap. Consider that the average American technology worker earns $110,000 per year. Meanwhile, their Indian counterparts earn about $32,000 — Indians work for one-third the price.

Why hire an American when you can hire an Indian to do the same job for a fraction of the price?

Offshoring explains the rapid growth of India’s technology sector, 80% of which comes from exports alone — far more than China at the same stage of its rise in 2001.

Interestingly, America’s trade deficit in services with India was just $3.2 billion — fairly small when compared with other countries. This has given the false impression that offshoring is not a problem.

The reality is much more grim. The scale of offshoring is obscured by the fact that Indian services — which are largely “branch plants” of American technology companies — also service non-American markets.

RELATED: Why tariffs beat treaties in a world that cheats

Amy Laughinghouse via iStock/Getty Images

America’s tech giants rake in large profits by offshoring production to India. In turn, India’s government collects the tax revenue, and Indian people benefit from new jobs. But as usual, the American people don’t factor into this equation — yet another example of Wall Street screwing over ordinary Americans.

The price of a rupee

In my book “Reshore: How Tariffs Will Bring Our Jobs Home and Revive the American Dream,” I explain how offshoring hurts American workers in three main ways.

First, it relocates American jobs abroad, causing unemployment. Second, it suppresses wages by flooding the labor market with laid-off workers and by putting Americans in direct wage competition with cheaper foreign workers. Third, it redirects investment — especially in education — from the United States to India.

How many technology jobs have been lost to India? Although the exact number is impossible to calculate, we can estimate. A good starting point is to look at the number of Indian jobs supported by U.S. dollars. Remember, 5.4 million Indians work in the technology sector, and 80% of the revenue comes from exports — mostly purchased by the United States.

Why hire an American when you can hire an Indian to do the same job, for a fraction of the price?

If we assume a one-to-one corollary between an Indian job and an American job, then we can guess that 4.3 million jobs have been displaced. In reality, this is probably too generous — Americans are more productive than their Indian counterparts. Either way, the number of lost jobs are in the millions.

And those job losses ripple through the labor market.

Displaced workers compete for fewer domestic jobs, driving down wages. At the same time, employers can offshore tech services to India with ease, which drags wages down further.

It’s a global race to the bottom — and American workers have the farthest to fall.

Offshoring more than jobs

But an even more nefarious cost of offshoring hits directly at our kids’ futures. Offshoring reduces the demand for skilled labor in America and increases it in India, incentivizing investment ineducation abroad while neglecting our own schools. It’s not only cheaper to hire Indians, it’s also cheaper to train them.

The proof is in the pudding. In 2004, 51,000 Americans graduated with computer science degrees and 4,000 in software engineering. By 2024, these numbers had doubled to approximately 100,000 and 8,000 respectively — not bad.

RELATED: Read it and weep: Tariffs work, and the numbers prove it

GCShutter via iStock/Getty Images

However, when compared to India, 80,000 Indian students graduated with computer science degrees in 2004 and 5,000 in software engineering. By 2024, these numbers had tripled to over 250,000 and 15,000 respectively. Despite having a much smaller technology industry that is entirely dependent on American investment, India now trains more people for the technology industry than the country that hires them — and the number of graduates is increasing faster.

American technology companies demand educated Indians rather than educated Americans. As such, major American technology companies pour money into Indian universities.

Bring services back home

The United States has been pillaged for decades. The inability to manufacture basic goods poses a stark threat to the nation. The same is increasingly true of technology services: Americans are taking the back seat in education, employment, and innovation.

President Trump’s instincts on tariffs are correct, but regarding India, the reality is that tariffs are akin to fighting last year’s war. We need to either tariff offshored services or tax the wages paid to foreigners so that there is no cost advantage to hiring Indians (or anyone else). If not, America will depend on foreigners for goods and services — and there will be nothing left at home.

​Opinion & analysis, Donald trump, Tariffs, Tariff trade wars, Trade, Offshore, Reshore, Jobs, Employment, Deficit, Big tech, Technology, Bangalore, India, Boston, Silicon valley, China, Imports, Exports