Is this just another cycle, or is it the END? Martin Armstrong of Armstrong Economics published an article this week about the so-called Socrates program and how [more…]
Meta collaborates with conservative activist Robby Starbuck to curb political bias in AI
(NaturalNews) Facebook parent company Meta has partnered with conservative activist Robby Starbuck to address political and ideological bias in its AI systems, …
HHS data: Over 11,000 migrant children placed with unvetted sponsors under Biden administration
(NaturalNews) Between 2021 and 2025, over 11,000 unaccompanied migrant children were placed with sponsors who were neither parents nor legal guardians and were …
Louisiana’s lawsuit against Roblox fuels debate over mandatory age verification and digital privacy
(NaturalNews) Attorney General Liz Murrill filed a lawsuit against Roblox, accusing the platform of failing to protect children due to its lack of age verificat…
Bank execs pressured by Obama and Biden administrations to DEBANK conservative clients
(NaturalNews) Senior officials at major U.S. banks claim they were pressured by regulators under the Obama and Biden administrations to deny services to politic…
Trump calls for Fed Gov. Lisa Cook to resign amid mortgage allegations
(NaturalNews) President Donald Trump has demanded that Fed Governor Lisa Cook resign immediately, citing allegations of mortgage fraud tied to two properties sh…
VAPING now deemed as GATEWAY DRUG to SMOKING CIGARETTES as major global research study reveals startling statistics for kids and teens
(NaturalNews) Itâs not just cigarettes that are horrible for your health, itâs vaping too. These nifty little nicotine delivery devices donât just deliver fre…
Babies in Wi-Fi-dense homes face triple risk of developmental delays: Study warns of emerging health crisis
(NaturalNews) A study links high wireless radiation exposure to developmental delays in infants, including problem-solving and motor skill challenges. Babies…
WATCH: Mob Attacks ICE Agents in San Francisco
Knife-wielding assailant who threatened ICE agents’ families is transgender militant, reports indicate
$3,000 for hail damage? How you can protect yourself from the new rental car scam
Car rental companies are quietly charging unsuspecting customers thousands of dollars in so-called damage fees — often weeks after the car has been returned. These charges are frequently unsupported, barely documented, and nearly impossible to dispute unless you know exactly how the system works.
In one case, a customer returned a rental car in Denver — no issues, no incident, nothing unusual. Then came a $3,000 bill in the mail. The reason? Alleged hail damage.
The roof and hood are often where hail damage occurs, and ironically, those are the areas most renters fail to photograph.
There were no photos provided at the time of the return. No damage inspection report. No conversation with a manager on the spot. The only justification given weeks later was that the company pulled weather data and determined that he must have been near a hailstorm — therefore, he was automatically responsible.
No proof
That’s right. Not proof that the car was damaged under his care. Not proof that damage even existed when he returned the car. Just the assumption that because he rented a car in Colorado during summer, and a hailstorm occurred somewhere in the region, he was liable.
This happens far more often than most people realize.
Rental companies are increasingly relying on post-return claims. These are often triggered not by their employees noticing anything during check-in, but by someone (often with the help of AI) discovering a ding or scratch later — sometimes days later — and assuming it must have been the last renter. Or worse, they may have known the damage was already there before but didn’t assign the cost to the correct customer and are now looking for someone else to pin it on.
Renter’s burden
What makes this so dangerous is that the process overwhelmingly favors the rental companies. The burden of proof is on you. You’re guilty until you can prove otherwise. Most renters have no idea what they agreed to when they signed the contract. Most don’t take thorough photos before driving off the lot. And by the time the bill shows up, it’s too late.
Now let’s be clear about what’s really happening.
The rental contract says you’re responsible for any damage that occurs during the rental period — regardless of fault. It doesn’t matter if a tree branch falls on the car while it’s parked or if a shopping cart scratches the side at a grocery store. Even acts of nature like hail or flood damage fall on your shoulders.
If there’s no photo record or inspection at the time of pickup or return, the company is free to decide when the damage happened — and guess who they choose every time.
Hail no
In this Denver case, the customer did one thing right: He checked the weather history from his phone and confirmed that he was never near a hailstorm during the rental period. His phone’s GPS and time-stamped data backed it up. But even with that evidence, the company still tried to push the charge.
They claimed they use an external hail and storm database to verify damage. But the customer wasn’t in the affected area. There was no damage noted at the time of return. And there were no inspection records. Eventually, after escalating the matter and demanding documentation, the company backed down.
Only then did they admit they were “open to further conversation” and dropped the claim. No apology. No acknowledgment of fault. Just silence.
RELATED: Don’t get SCAMMED by fake parking tickets!
UCG/Getty Images
A new revenue stream
This is not the exception. It’s the model.
This is a serious consumer issue, and it’s getting worse. Post-return damage claims are now a revenue stream for some rental operations. And many of them outsource these cases to third-party claim companies that are incentivized to collect, regardless of the facts.
So what can you do?
Protect yourself
You can start by protecting yourself before the rental even begins. That means taking full photo documentation of the vehicle — front, back, both sides, the roof, hood, bumpers, wheels, undercarriage if possible, and the interior. Use your phone’s camera. Those photos carry location data and time stamps. That’s your legal defense.
The roof and hood are often where hail damage occurs, and ironically, those are the areas most renters fail to photograph. You’ll never see the top of the car unless you intentionally document it, and that’s exactly what these companies rely on.
When returning the car, do the same thing. Photograph it again, preferably at the return location, clearly showing its condition and surroundings. If there’s no one available to do a return walk-through with you, document everything yourself. Don’t assume that handing in the keys means you’re in the clear. Some companies inspect returned vehicles hours — or even days — after the fact.
Know your rights
Now let’s address the bigger question: Do you actually have any rights if a company decides to file a damage claim against you?
The answer is yes, but you’ll have to fight for them.
If you receive a damage claim, you have the right to request documentation. That includes photographs of the damage, time and date of the inspection, a copy of the repair invoice, and a full record of the chain of custody.
That means: When was the damage noted, by whom, and how did they confirm it happened during your rental?
Most people never ask for this. But when you do, it puts the company in a position where they must justify the claim — not just demand payment.
If they can’t produce that documentation, or if what they provide is vague or missing time stamps, that’s a red flag.
You can dispute the charge directly with the company, and if they won’t respond or negotiate, you can escalate it to their corporate office. If you paid with a credit card — and you should — file a dispute. In many cases, the credit card issuer will take your side if the company can’t substantiate the claim.
Some renters have even taken these disputes to small-claims court — and won. Not just because they were innocent, but because the rental company failed to provide the most basic evidence.
A transparency problem
But here’s the reality: You shouldn’t have to go through that. You shouldn’t have to become a lawyer, meteorologist, and forensic investigator just to rent a car and return it without being charged for damages you didn’t cause.
So here’s the bottom line.
The rental car industry has a transparency problem. Customers are being blamed for damages they didn’t cause, and the companies making these accusations are not being held to any standard of proof.
And until that changes, your best defense is documentation.
Take photos. Keep receipts. Ask for a walk-around when possible. If there’s visible damage, request a different vehicle or get it marked on your paperwork. If a claim arises, don’t ignore it, but don’t blindly pay it either.
This isn’t about one company or one customer. This is about an entire industry that has been allowed to operate in the shadows when it comes to post-rental damage claims. That has to change.
But until it does, protect yourself — and spread the word.
Rental cars, Damages, Post-return claims, Lifestyle, How-to, Drivers, Align cars
Ex-DHS Official Believes He’s “Next” To Be Raided By FBI Following Trump Admin Search Of Former CIA Director Bolton’s Home
Former DHS Deputy Chief of Staff Miles Taylor pushes propaganda on MSM.
Putin Vetoed Hypersonic Missile Strike On Zelensky’s Office, Belarusian President Says
“There would have been nothing left, if the strike would have taken place,” added Lukashenko.
WATCH: Loitering Vagrant Arrested at DC Burger Joint Shortly After VP Vance Visit
“These guys had control of Union Station before now.”
Was ‘Scooby-Doo’ actually atheist propaganda for children?
Does “Scooby-Doo” teach children the core philosophical tenets of atheism?
I recently saw an atheist claim that “Scooby-Doo” was created to teach children about rationality and skepticism because every episode begins with a supernatural event — like a haunting ghost and unexplained phenomena — and ends with a “natural explanation” (i.e., it’s just a person in a mask).
I saw this claim on Reddit:
I just realized scooby-doo was made to teach kids skepticism and rationality
Suddenly it makes sense why my ultra religious mother ended up forbidding me from watching it as a kid. Last night, it suddenly occurred to me based on what I could vaguely recall about the show before I was banned from it that every episode was about something supernatural happening and then getting proven to have a non-supernatural cause. I looked it up and it turns out that was exactly the case.
This argument got me thinking and raised two important questions:
Is “Scooby-Doo” naturalist propaganda for children?How strongly does the plot of a generic “Scooby-Doo” episode bolster the argument for naturalism?
Subversive Scooby
When you stop and think about it, “Scooby-Doo” is actually kind of subversive.
It teaches children that whenever we think something is supernatural, it really just has a natural explanation. It drills into young minds that the right answer is always the non-supernatural one. The ghosts are never real, the curses are always fake, and the monsters are just people in costumes.
There’s always a natural explanation. And by reinforcing this idea over and over, it teaches children that believing anything supernatural is irrational.
God isn’t one more cause among the many other causes in the universe. He’s not just another thing pushing particles around.
“Scooby-Doo” is not a neutral show. It’s naturalistic indoctrination.
And here’s why that’s a problem: The argument that “every time we investigate, we find a natural explanation, so everything must have a natural explanation” is the same argument atheists use to claim that God isn’t real.
Fatal flaw
The subversive argument of the “Scooby-Doo” plot is not only a problem because it’s the same one that atheists use, but it’s a problem because it’s not a good argument.
In fact, it’s a really bad one.
First, even if you grant for the sake of argument that a natural explanation is found on the other side of a supernatural cause, it doesn’t require that all explanations are natural. That’s just logically invalid. It’s like saying, “All the swans I’ve seen are white; therefore all swans must be white,” or, “Every time I walk into a house, I see carpet; therefore all houses have carpet.”
These are inductive overreaches. It’s completely fallacious reasoning. Still, there’s an even deeper problem.
RELATED: How Joe Rogan dismantled the Big Bang with one sentence — and made atheists squirm
ra2studio/iStock/Getty Images Plus
Atheists believe that if God existed, then we should be able to see him directly intervening in the world in a visible, testable way. They think that if we hear a weird sound in the attic, we should be able to climb up there and find God directly causing the sound.
But this is a bizarre line of logic, because that’s not how God is understood in theism. God isn’t one more cause among the many other causes in the universe. He’s not just another thing pushing particles around. Instead, God is the one who makes the whole universe possible in the first place.
Worldmaker
Consider J.R.R. Tolkien. When you read “The Lord of the Rings,” you don’t see Tolkien himself in the story. Rather, you see Frodo walking to Mordor, Gandalf giving advice, and Aragorn being born from parents. You’d never see Tolkien manipulating Middle-earth — he’s nowhere to be seen.
If you lived in that world, you might think based on your experience that everything was caused by something else in that world. The characters have their own internal causes, and yet their ultimate existence and explanation is found in what? J.R.R. Tolkien. He brought all of it into being.
Notice that even though Tolkien is the ultimate explanation for everything in his world, you cannot find him directly causing anything in his world.
That’s how God relates to our world. He’s the reason anything exists at all. Just as Tolkien is the cause of everything in Middle-earth without being a character in it, God is the cause of everything in our universe without being a natural object within it.
So to expect that you can “see God” in the chain of natural causes is like tearing apart the pages of a novel looking for the author’s actual fingerprints.
The final answer
Still, there is a much bigger philosophical problem with this argument that atheists hate to acknowledge.
If you say that everything has an explanation, then you are forced to ask: Where does the chain of explanations stop?
Sure, perhaps natural things are explained by other natural things. But what explains those? And what explains the natural things that explain those natural things? It’s a circular argument that results in infinite regress, which produces contradictions and ultimately explains nothing.
That’s not rational.
There has to be something at the end of the chain, something that explains everything else but is not explained by anything else. Something that exists by the necessity of its own nature.
If the supernatural foundation of all reality has a mind, then that’s God.
That thing, whatever it is, must be radically different from everything else. It’s not one more link in the chain — it’s the foundation of the chain. And if it’s not caused, not contingent, and not dependent on anything else, then it’s not “natural.” It’s supernatural, and it’s fundamentally different from all of the “natural” stuff.
Once you realize this, you’re forced to consider: Does this supernatural foundation have a mind?
And what do you find in the universe it caused? You find minds. Information embedded in DNA. Consciousness. Reason. Intelligibility. Purpose. Order. Morality.
None of these things we would expect to get from mindless matter. These are exactly the things an intelligent mind produces. We know this because we ourselves possess minds. So if the fundamental cause of everything contains the power to bring forth minds, intelligibility, and moral reality, then the most reasonable conclusion is that it, too, has a mind.
And if the supernatural foundation of all reality has a mind, then that’s God.
Maybe the real mystery isn’t whether or not “Scooby-Doo” was debunking ghosts. The real mystery is why so many atheists think that repeating a cartoon plotline counts as an argument against the existence of God.
Atheism, Christianity, Christian, God, Scooby doo, Cartoons, Children, Propaganda, Faith
Free at Last: Why Lucy Connolly Matters to the Trump Administration
Lucy Connolly is now free, after serving four months of a 31-month sentence for an angry Tweet she wrote and then deleted a few hours [more…]
Male HS choral director arrested on sex trafficking charges, accused of meeting underage student through LGBTQ dating app
A Massachusetts music teacher is accused of sex trafficking by paying a minor — whom he met through an LGBTQ dating app — for sex acts.
The Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office said in a press release, “A Brockton High School instructor has been arraigned on human trafficking charges after an investigation by the Massachusetts State Police and Brockton Police, Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy J. Cruz has announced.”
‘We are deeply troubled by the allegations in this case.’
Matthew Cunningham, 35, was arrested at his Brockton home around 10:20 a.m. Tuesday by members of the Massachusetts State Police Special Services Section High Risk Victim Squad and Brockton Police.
Cunningham pleaded not guilty to charges of sexual conduct for a fee and trafficking of a person for sexual servitude during his arraignment in Brockton District Court.
Cunningham’s bail was set at $25,000.
However, the judge set specific conditions if he is released on bail.
The Enterprise reported that bail conditions include “home confinement with GPS monitoring, staying away from and not contacting the victim, staying away from Brockton High School, refraining from using social media, relinquishing his passport, and staying in Massachusetts.”
The Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office said the child sex crime charges stem from months-long investigations by Massachusetts State Police and Brockton Police.
“The allegations are that on April 27, 2025, Cunningham met up with an underage male victim, performed a sexual act on the victim, and then paid the victim on an app,” the DA’s office stated. “App administrators contacted the FBI after flagging the monetary transaction between an adult and a minor.”
Assistant District Attorney Jason Blanchette claimed Cunningham asked the alleged victim if he was willing to engage in sex acts for money through Grindr — a dating app geared toward the LGBTQ+ community, the Enterprise reported.
More from the outlet:
After connecting on the app, Cunningham allegedly picked up the victim and drove him to his house, where he paid the victim for sex acts, Blanchette said. […]
After the encounter, the prosecution said the victim recognized Cunningham as the choral director at his school and grew uncomfortable with the encounter.
Brendan Kelly — Cunningham’s court-appointed defense attorney — said his client was not aware that the alleged victim was under 18 years old or that he was a student at Brockton High School.
According to Grindr’s community guidelines, users on the dating app must be at least 18 years old.
Brockton Public Schools said Cunningham was placed on paid administrative leave as soon as school officials found out about the allegations.
“Brockton Public Schools learned today of the arrest of Brockton High School teacher Matthew Cunningham, and he was immediately placed on paid administrative leave,” Brockton Public Schools said in a statement released on Tuesday, according to CBS News. “We are deeply troubled by the allegations in this case.”
The ongoing investigation will include a forensic examination of Cunningham’s cell phone, according to the district attorney’s office.
Cunningham is scheduled for a Sept. 18 court appearance.
Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up here!
Child sex crimes, Teacher arrested, Teacher sex scandal, Matthew cunningham, Lgbtq, Sex trafficking, Human trafficking, Crime, Massachusetts, Brockton, Grindr
Think Tank Urges Dems to Drop These 45 Terms That Turn Off Normies
“We’ve yet to hear a voter volunteer any of the phrases below except as a form of derision or parody of Democrats.”
National Guard Mobilizing Across 19 States to Clean Up Democratic Party’s Alarming Failures
Soldiers will support sweeping crackdown to arrest and deport criminal illegal aliens while restoring law and order in metro areas gutted by rogue Democratic leaders
The radical left is poisoning our schools — here’s how we fight back
Two hundred and fifty years ago, my great-grandmother’s great-grandfather pledged his life, his fortune, and his sacred honor to help forge this great nation.
In the centuries since, Americans have celebrated triumphs, endured hardships, and mourned tragedies. Our union, like Old Glory herself, bears scars — marks of a nation that is imperfect but resilient.
We must advocate for an education that promotes building and creating, that equips young people with the tools to succeed in a complex world.
While the United States was founded on a bedrock of Enlightenment values and principles, they are under ideological assault — not from external enemies, but from within our own K-12 schools.
In order for us to preserve this constitutional republic for posterity, we must not only expose these destructive far-left, anti-Western-civilization ideologies and their adherents, but we must also counter them by offering a better vision — one rooted in the timeless principles that built this nation and can guide future generations.
We need to fight for a “more perfect union” that is noticeably better today than yesterday. Unfortunately, Wormtongue has the ear of education.
History hijacked
Cloaked under the guise of “culture” and “history,” ethnic studies is a far-left political programming that brings together a “Red-Green Alliance” bent on ending capitalism and overturning stability.
Proponents such as the teachers’ unions, Black Lives Matter, the Democratic Socialists of America, and anti-Israel activists are using K-12 schools to advance their agenda by seeding their radical ideology into curriculums and training the youth to be social justice street activists.
Based on cultural Marxist Paulo Freire’s work, ethnic studies teaches children to obsess over their identities, find oppression and racism in every corner of society, and resent those who are perceived to have more “privilege” than them.
It then presents students with a new set of “heroes” and idols such as the Black Panther Party, the Third World Liberation Front, and even Che Guevara.
RELATED: ‘Critical theory is the framework’ used to train teachers: K-12 public schools ‘saturated’ with CRT
mj0007/iStock/Getty Images Plus
Ethnic studies then offers a utopian vision, promising “liberation” through street activism and the relentless critique and dismantling of societal norms — a process eerily reminiscent of Mao’s Cultural Revolution.
This corrosive ideology thrives on destruction, not creation. It fuels resentment and division, teaching children to see themselves and their neighbors as victims or villains in an endless struggle.
Future forged
Despite this, we can do better. We need to do better. We must advocate for an education that promotes building and creating, that equips young people with the tools to succeed in a complex world.
American youth are hungry for meaningful change, lasting self-confidence, and inspirational leadership. They deserve to be taught what it takes to be successful, what it means to be American, and what it requires.
It starts with faith — the belief in things hoped for but not yet seen, like a “more perfect union.” Young people need to trust that their future, and the future of this nation, can be shaped through their efforts. They should be encouraged to dream boldly and believe in their potential to achieve greatness — but to be humble enough to admit their mistakes.
There needs to be a renewal of integrity and an emphasis on valuing a person of his word, someone who means what he says and says what he means. This fosters societal trust, which is a hallmark of a thriving culture.
The sacrifices made today — whether time, comfort, or ease — pave the way for the outcomes we seek tomorrow.
Additionally, high societal trust requires taking on great responsibility. We need to help the youth understand that there is fulfillment in taking ownership over their own actions and the consequences that follow. As much has been given, much is required in return.
Prioritizing effort is also essential. A commitment to hard work and quality repetition forges habits and automaticity, and this leads to competence. Moreover, making the little things matter can be the difference between success and failure.
Finally, we must assist the youth in learning that making proper sacrifices is crucial to stable, long-term successes. The sacrifices made today — whether time, comfort, or ease — pave the way for the outcomes we seek tomorrow. Success is a byproduct of the right sacrifices at the right time.
Republic renewed
Two and a half centuries ago, the founders put everything they had on the line to establish this republic. It is now upon us and our children to keep it.
By teaching faith, integrity, responsibility, effort, and sacrifice, we empower American youth to make today better than yesterday — and to shape a future that honors the sacrifices of those who came before us.
America’s children deserve a vision that uplifts, not one that tears down.
Let’s give them the tools to build a nation that, while scarred, remains a beacon of hope and opportunity for all — a renewed and reinvigorated “shining city upon a hill.”
Woke, Woke culture, Ethnic studies, Blm, Black lives matter, Radical left, Leftism, Children, School system, Education
As DEI collapses, billionaires fund radical woke math
Jim Simons’ mathematical skills helped transform him from a prize-winning academic at Harvard and MIT into a legendary financier whose algorithmic models made Renaissance Technologies one of the most successful hedge funds in history. After his death last year, one of his consequential bequests went to his daughter, Liz, who oversees the Heising-Simons Foundation and its nearly billion-dollar endowment.
What Liz Simons has chosen to do with that inheritance might have surprised her father. Jim Simons devoted much of his charitable giving to basic research in mathematics and science, but his daughter’s foundation is moving in a very different direction. The Heising-Simons Foundation and similar organizations are supercharging a movement to remake K-12 mathematics education according to social justice principles.
Students are placed at a disadvantage when mathematical instruction is embedded in critical theory.
The revamp is profound. They reject well-established practices of math instruction while infusing lessons with racial and gender themes. The goal is to motivate disadvantaged students while dispensing with the traditional features of math — like numerical computation, which they struggle with on standardized tests — considered an oppressive feature of white supremacist culture.
Philanthropy-funded ‘anti-racist’ math
In many quarters, including corporations and universities, diversity, equity, and inclusion programs are in retreat due to pressure from the Trump administration and the courts. Not so in public education, with curricula that are locally controlled and largely insulated from the dictates of Washington.
That allows progressive foundations and like-minded charitable trusts to continue to pour millions of dollars into reshaping math education for black and Latino kids — including an $800,000 grant this year from the Heising-Simons Foundation — even though no credible research exists showing that the social justice approach improves their performance.
“Politicians and legislatures, even school boards,” are often too “hamstrung” to get things done, Bob Hughes, the director of K-12 education at the Gates Foundation, said at an online symposium on the need for racial equity policies in America’s classrooms. Philanthropy, he added, faces fewer barriers in making rapid changes.
The Gates Foundation has been a leader in the promotion of anti-racist math instruction. It supported a project called “A Pathway to Equitable Math Instruction.” The project discards basic tenets of learning, like asking students to “show their work” and find the “right” answer as vestiges of “white supremacy culture.” The pathway is promoted by EdTrust West, which also receives support from the Spencer Foundation, the Heising-Simons Foundation, and other major donors.
The Gates and Heising-Simons foundations have both supported TODOS Mathematics for All, an Arizona-based organization that calls for elevating diversity, equity, and inclusion practices and anti-racist activism into all math instruction, with over $553,750 in grants in recent years. “We can no longer believe that a focus on curriculum, instruction, and assessment alone will be enough to prepare our children for survival in the world. We need anti-racist conversations for ourselves and for our children,” TODOS President Linda Fulmore announced in 2020.
Last year, the group hosted an hour-long webinar on “2SLGBTQIA+ identity in mathematics education.” During the event, a speaker expounded at length on various queer and indigenous identity groups while spending virtually no time on math-related curriculum or instruction.
At one point, the presenter erroneously claimed that there are “15.3 billion students in U.S. high schools” — a figure that would require the entire global population to be enrolled in American secondary education twice over. The speaker likely meant to say million.
‘Race-centered’ math
The foundations similarly fund practical lessons that put race at the center of math instruction. In Alexandria, Virginia, for example, the Heising-Simons Foundation supported a public-school program that encouraged kindergartners through second-graders to count the characters in picture books by race. At the end of each session, teachers guided students in creating racial scorecards for each book, then voting to select those with the fewest white characters. The exercise was presented as mathematics education.
Jo Boaler, a controversial professor of education at Stanford University who championed the push to remove eighth-grade algebra from San Francisco’s public schools in the name of equity, traces her support to this network of foundations. The Gates Foundation and Valhalla Foundation, which was founded by Scott Cook, the co-founder of tech firm Intuit, have long funded her math education project called YouCubed.
These deep-pocket donors also fund Danny Bernard Martin, a professor of math education at the University of Illinois at Chicago and a leading voice of what critics call “woke math.”
Over the past six years, the Racial Justice in Early Mathematics Project, which Martin co-leads at the Erikson Institute in Chicago, has received nearly $2.5 million from the Heising-Simons Foundation. This year, the foundation announced an additional $800,000 grant to help the project develop tool kits for wider implementation among teachers, administrators, and researchers.
Martin’s views extend far beyond typical calls for educational equity. He regards mathematics instruction as fundamentally a “white supremacist construct” that inflicts “epistemological violence” on black students. In his estimation, even DEI programs are too conservative — mere accommodations “rooted in the fictions of white imaginaries” and designed to appease “white logics and sensibilities.”
The solution Martin proposes is radical: Black students should seek instruction exclusively from black teachers at “independent black institutions.” They should resist the temptation of “advanced coursework and mathematics-related employment” and instead engage in “walkouts and boycotts” to protest against mathematics education as it currently exists.
Photo by georgeclerk via Getty Images
The very structure of math instruction, Martin contends, has dehumanized black students through low test scores and failing grades.
The ideas of the Racial Justice in Early Mathematics Project and its leaders have reverberated through America’s classrooms. California’s new mathematics curriculum framework, which guides K-12 education statewide, repeatedly cites Martin.
Educators have sharply criticized the framework for leaning heavily on politicized concepts of math. The document suggests, for instance, that teachers “take a justice-oriented perspective” when providing instruction and discourages the use of “tracking” — or the practice of separating students into different classrooms based on their abilities.
Educators push back
Williamson Evers, a former assistant secretary of education and a fellow at the conservative-leaning Independent Institute, has been monitoring what he calls the “woke math” movement for years. “It’s very important to have math skills,” he told RealClearInvestigations.
Evers rejects the identity-based claims made by Martin and others who have called for minority students to abandon math education over alleged racism. “There are mathematicians and scientists on every continent from every background, and this idea of boycotting education would harm black schoolchildren.”
Elizabeth Statmore, a math teacher at the elite Lowell High School in San Francisco and a critic of social justice math, says the way to improve the performance of black and Latino students lies in the nitty-gritty, such as better teaching, holding students accountable, and providing them with more academic and emotional support.
Critics say the emphasis on prose over calculation will exacerbate the very disparities that social justice advocates claim to address.
“But it’s not sexy; they’re not on the keynote circuit like Danny Bernard Martin and Jo Boaler,” Statmore said. “They’re building a brand, not doing the kind of math education research that is helping to improve outcomes for disadvantaged children.”
Representatives of the Heising-Simons Foundation, the Erikson Institute, and Martin did not respond to requests for comment.
The Heising-Simons Foundation’s focus on racializing math education reflects its broader ideological commitments. Like many progressive foundations, it uses its significant funds to advance a range of left-wing policies that might have a hard time establishing themselves without billionaire support.
The foundation has also donated to PolicyLink, the organization behind DefundPolice.org, and to the Anti-Police Terror Project, which advocates for abolishing police departments in high-crime cities like Oakland, California. Liz Simons was also among a small clique of California megadonors behind the push to elect progressive prosecutors such as George Gascón in Los Angeles and Chesa Boudin in San Francisco. They declined to pursue felony charges against a range of violent offenders over concerns about racial equity.
The attempt to reimagine mathematics through the lens of critical race theory isn’t new — scholars have been working along these lines since the 1980s. They argue that historical racial oppression continues to influence everything from geometry curricula to standardized testing. Traditional emphases on objectivity, rigorous standards, and subject-matter mastery should be replaced, the scholars argue, with ideological exercises designed to promote racial and social consciousness.
What is new is the scale and speed of adoption. As America has grappled with questions of racial justice in recent years, billionaire foundations have provided the resources to implement these ideas widely in both public and private schools.
The donors appear motivated by a deep sense of ideological commitment to righting past wrongs related to racial injustice.
At the 2020 education donor symposium, Liz Simons recalled her experience working briefly as a Spanish bilingual teacher in an impoverished community in Oakland. “The much larger systemic problems,” she witnessed, Simons said, guided her to the goal of shaping early childhood education.
Na’ilah Suad Nasir, president of the Spencer Foundation, noted that she previously worked as the vice chancellor of “equity and inclusion” at the University of California, Berkeley. Expanding racial equity in education, she said, has been her “life’s work.”
Widening disparities
When it comes to math instruction, social justice means stripping it of basic features like numbers. In workshops hosted by the Racial Justice in Early Mathematics Project in 2023, the group promoted “numberless word problems” — mathematical exercises stripped of numerical computation. The method, instructors explain, is designed to counter “European ways of knowing and doing.”
Sisa Pon Renie, one presenter, spoke of wanting to challenge the “persistent myth that math is just abstract and without any cultural relevance.” The project champions this numberless approach as essential for “helping children understand how mathematics might be an important tool to understand social issues and promote justice.”
But critics say the emphasis on prose over calculation will exacerbate the very disparities that social justice advocates claim to address.
“Imagine you’re a Cambodian refugee, and you get some math problem that’s loaded with prose,” Evers, of the Independent Institute, said. “Maybe you’re very good at the figures part, the calculating part, the mathematical part.”
Such students, he argued, are placed at a disadvantage when mathematical instruction is embedded in critical-theory frameworks and dense with English text. “They unnecessarily load these things down, make it harder, and it’s not even math. It’s an inadequate mode of teaching.”
The real-world consequences of these approaches have played out most dramatically in San Francisco. A decade ago, officials removed Algebra 1 from middle schools, arguing that the change would give black and Latino students, who were underrepresented in the math class, more time to prepare while avoiding placing them in lower-level tracks.
David Margulies, a parent involved with the San Francisco community, observed that families wanting their children to take Algebra 1 in eighth grade shifted away from public to private schools, online learning, and homeschooling. Students who don’t take the math class in middle school find it more difficult to take calculus in high school.
RELATED: Major university caught in new DEI cover-up
Photo by via Getty Images
“Families figured out how important this is, and they are looking elsewhere,” he noted.
A 2023 Stanford study found that San Francisco’s Algebra 1 experiment did little to close racial achievement gaps. Black enrollment in Advanced Placement math classes remained unchanged, while Latino participation increased by 1%.
Meanwhile, education systems that have increased rather than decreased academic rigor have seen notable improvements in black student performance. In 2019, Dallas public schools began automatically enrolling students who performed well on state exams in middle-school algebra. The program increased black participation in advanced mathematics from 17% in 2018 to 43% in 2023.
Walking it back
Last year, during a Racial Justice in Early Mathematics Project webinar titled “Who Is Labeled Smart?” Martin addressed the backlash against San Francisco’s push for educational equity. He toned down his scathing critique of merit-based advanced education programs that he believes harm black and Latino students and made a surprising statement about his own son’s schooling.
“I’m guilty, I’m guilty,” Martin said, almost sheepishly. “My son is, quote unquote, in one of those tracks.”
Editor’s note: This article was originally published by RealClearInvestigations and made available via RealClearWire.
Opinion & analysis, Heising-simons foundation, Woke agenda, Woke math, Diversity equity and inclusion, Liz simons, Social justice, Jim simons, Harvard, Mit, Woke capital, Mathematics, K-12 education, Standards, White supremacy, Race, Racism, Boycotts, Activism, Gates foundation, Realclearinvestigation, Erikson institute, Danny bernard martin, Jo boaler
Ghislaine Maxwell Says Father Was Intelligence Asset, Trump ‘Was Never Inappropriate’: DOJ Transcripts
He was long speculated to have been a secret agent for the Mossad, the Israeli intelligence office that is equivalent to the CIA.
