Is this just another cycle, or is it the END? Martin Armstrong of Armstrong Economics published an article this week about the so-called Socrates program and how [more…]
The vindication of Booker T. Washington
Christopher Wolfe’s thoughtful essay at the American Mind on Booker T. Washington, leisure, and work stirred some fond memories from years ago of making a friend by reading a book.
He was an old black man, and I was an old white man. We were both native Angelenos and had been just about old enough to drive when the Watts riots broke out in 1965. But that was half a century and a lifetime ago, and we hadn’t known each another.
If you read ‘Up from Slavery,’ you will be reading an American classic and will be getting to know a man who ranks among the greatest Americans of all time.
Los Angeles is a big place, a home to many worlds. Now we were white-haired professors, reading a book together, and we became friends. His name was Kimasi, and he has since gone to a better world.
We were spending a week with a dozen other academics reading Booker T. Washington’s autobiography, “Up from Slavery.” Washington was born a slave in Franklin County, Virginia, just a few years before the Civil War began. He gained his freedom through Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and the Union victory in the war. With heroic determination, he got himself an education and went on to found the Tuskegee Normal and Industrial Institute in Alabama, where he remained principal for the rest of his life.
After Frederick Douglass died in 1895, Washington became, without comparison, the most well-known and influential black American living. By the beginning of the 20th century, as John Hope Franklin would write, he was “one of the most powerful men in the United States.” “Up from Slavery,” published in 1901, sold 100,000 copies before Washington died in 1915.
It is a great American book. Modern Library ranks it third on its list of the best nonfiction books in the English language of the 20th century. But there was a reason why Kimasi and I were reading this great book when we were old men rather than when we were young men back in the riotous 1960s.
Even before Washington died, and while he was still the most famous and influential black man in America, other black leaders began to discredit him and question his way of dealing with the plight and aspirations of black Americans. These critics, whom Washington sometimes called “the intellectuals,” were led by W.E.B. Du Bois, the first black American to receive a Ph.D. from Harvard and one of the founders of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.
So successful was this criticism that by the time Kimasi and I were in high school or heading off to college, the most fashionable opinion among intellectuals — black or white — was that Booker T. Washington was the worst of things for a black man. He was an “Uncle Tom.” (How “Uncle Tom” became a term of derision rather than the name of a heroic character is a story for another time.) And so, if Washington’s great book was mentioned at all to young Kimasi or me, it was mentioned in this negative light.
But fashions change, and, as Washington himself taught, merit is hard to resist. Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address and his Second Inaugural Address were dismissed and scoffed at by some “intellectuals” in his day; they are now generally recognized by informed and intelligent people around the world as the great speeches they are.
“Huckleberry Finn” scandalized polite opinion when it came out, because it was about an illiterate vagrant and other lowlifes and contained a lot of ungrammatical talk and bad spelling. A couple of generations later, Ernest Hemingway himself declared that “all modern American literature comes from one book” — Huckleberry Finn.
A couple of generations later still, in our own times, skittish librarians started removing the book from their shelves because it used language too dangerous for children.
The study of the past should shed light on what deserves praise, what deserves blame, and the grounds on which such judgments should be made. Americans being as fallible as the rest of mankind, as long as we are free to air opinions, there will be different opinions among us. Some of them may actually be true. And they will change from time to time, sometimes for good reasons, sometimes for no reason at all.
RELATED: Why can’t Americans talk honestly about race? Blame the ‘Civil Rights Baby Boomers’
Photo by Graphic House/Getty Images
In recent years, several scholars have helped bring back to light the greatness and goodness of Booker T. Washington. Even fashionable opinion is capable of justice, and no one wants to be deceived about what is truly good and great, so I hazard to predict that it will sometime become fashionable again to recognize Booker T. Washington as one of the greatest Americans ever.
Washington never held political office. But his life and work demonstrated that you don’t have to hold political office to be a statesman and that the noblest work of the statesman is to teach. The soul of what Washington sought to teach was that we, too, can rise up from slavery. It is an eternal possibility.
This was the central purpose of Booker T. Washington’s life and work: to liberate souls from enslavement to ignorance, prejudice, and degrading passions, the kind of slavery that makes us tyrants to those around us in the world we live in.
Washington saw that this freedom of the soul cannot be given to us by others. Good teachers and good parents and friends, through precept and example, can help us see this freedom and understand it, but we have to achieve it for ourselves. When we do, our souls are liberated to rule themselves by reflection and choice, with malice toward none, with charity for all.
If you read “Up from Slavery,” you will be reading an American classic. You will be getting to know a man who, in the quality of his mind and character, and in the significance of what he did in and with his life, ranks among the greatest Americans of all time — even with the man whose name he chose for himself. When we read this great book together in the ripeness of our years, Kimasi, who always winningly wore his heart on his sleeve, wept frequently and repeated, shaking his head, “I lived a life not knowing this man.”
Editor’s Note: This article was originally published at the American Mind.
Opinion & analysis, Race, Racism, Booker t. washington, Up from slavery, Literature, Memoir, Race relations, Slavery, Autobiography, W.e.b. du bois, Naacp, Equality, Uncle tom, Frederick douglass, Mark twain, Huckleberry finn, Library, History, Truth
VIRAL video: Evangelical claims Jesus took her to hell and showed her the fiery holding cell of Biggie Smalls
For decades, numerous people declared clinically dead have miraculously awakened with vivid descriptions of the heavenly realm. Stories of being enveloped by brilliant, warm light, strolling through indescribably beautiful landscapes, and reuniting with deceased loved ones (and even Jesus) are the subjects of many books written by people who have had near-death experiences. Many Christians view these heavenly visions as either true or at least plausible, believing that scripture corroborates such experiences.
But what about the opposite? What about visits to hell?
On this episode of “Strange Encounters,” a podcast that explores spiritual warfare from a biblical perspective, Rick dives into a wild story that’s gone viral: A woman named Queen Okeoma who claims to have seen the pits of hell — and the most iconic, influential rapper in history, Biggie Smalls, consumed by flames in a cell guarded by giant demons.
Okeoma is an author who has gained significant attention for her book, “Testimony: Life Changing Encounters in the Supernatural,” in which she claims to have experienced multiple out-of-body visits to heaven and hell.
On a recent podcast that’s gone viral, Okeoma shared one of her out-of-body experiences in which, she said, Jesus took her into hell and told her several things — that “the darkness is alive and it is its own separate evil entity,” that the flames of hell are “20,000 times hotter than the fire on the earth” and “are fed with brimstone night and day,” so “they will never go out,” and finally, that if she did not follow Him, He would “use [her]” to save others but that she would “die and go to hell.”
“I was physically out of my body in hell, standing beside Jesus Christ himself. It was pitch-black, and these demons had to be 13, 14, 15 feet tall, and they were standing in front of a jail cell. … And Biggie was holding the bars, but he was on fire from the inside,” she said, adding that Jesus told her that the rapper had rejected Him and instead “went to a fetish priest and got charms he carried around in his pocket to become famous.”
“When [the demons] put him back in his cell and closed the door, [Biggie] exploded on fire. And when my feet was an inch, maybe two inches, from that fire, I was back in my body,” she concluded, sobbing in gratitude that Jesus “let [her] live.”
Okeoma’s testimony has spurred much controversy. Some write her off as a kook, while others are driven to their knees in prayer.
Rick, who admits he doesn’t know anything about Okeoma or her faith, evaluates her harrowing testimony with biblical truth. “I don’t hear anything in what she’s saying that is now giving us some new revelation,” like “there are many ways to heaven,” which would automatically disqualify her story as false, he says.
“What she takes away from [her alleged divine encounter] is that Jesus is real, Jesus is the only way we can be redeemed, and hell is a very real place” — all truths confirmed by scripture. Further, Okeoma was driven to repentance following her experience — another factor that adds credibility to her account.
On top of that, her testimony has sparked significant online discussion and engagement, with many viewers sharing that either they or their friends and family have repented and professed faith in Jesus Christ after hearing her story.
“When I look at that, I’m not sure I’m ready to be so critical as some people have been,” says Rick.
To hear Okeoma’s first-person account and join Rick as he explores several other topics in the realm of spiritual warfare, watch the episode above.
Want more from Rick Burgess?
To enjoy more bold talk and big laughs, subscribe to BlazeTV — the largest multi-platform network of voices who love America, defend the Constitution, and live the American dream.
Strange encounters, Rick burgess, Heaven hell, Biggie, Biggie smalls, The notorious b.i.g., Queen okeoma, Christianity, Spiritual warfare, Angels and demons
“EMF Hazards Summit 2025” on BrightU: How 5G and smartphones are fueling a teen mental health crisis
(NaturalNews) On Day 3 of the “EMF Hazards Summit 2025,” Dr. Stephanie McCarter explored the sharp rise in serious health issues in young people, including a 53…
“The Future of Nutrition” by T. Colin Campbell: A call for a radical shift in dietary paradigm
(NaturalNews) Dr. T. Colin Campbell, with over 70 grant-years of peer-reviewed research and more than 350 published papers, is a leading authority in nutrition….
Health Ranger Report: Ron Paul sounds the alarm on the rise of government-corporate fusion
(NaturalNews) The Trump administration demands 15 percent royalties on Nvidia’s microchip sales to China, effectively turning private commerce into a taxpayer-f…
Russian forces push into Dnipropetrovsk region as peace talks falter
(NaturalNews) Russian forces have entered the Dnipropetrovsk region, marking a new phase in their offensive. This incursion into a key industrial hub near the D…
Quebec College of Physicians supports EUTHANASIA as “appropriate treatment” for severely ill infants
(NaturalNews) The Quebec College of Physicians has reaffirmed its support for allowing euthanasia in rare cases involving newborns with severe, untreatable cond…
U.S. Navy deploys warships near Venezuela amid tensions over drug trafficking allegations against Maduro
(NaturalNews) The U.S. Navy has deployed eight warships, including destroyers, an amphibious assault ship and Coast Guard-equipped vessels, to Caribbean and Pac…
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott signs three health-focused bills into law
(NaturalNews) Texas Gov. Greg Abbott signed three bipartisan health bills into law on Aug. 27, marking one of the most sweeping state nutrition reform efforts i…
HUMAN MEDICAL EXPERIMENT: The mRNA jabs are the most DANGEROUS unregulated, untested, unapproved âdrugâ ever used to sicken and murder Americans
(NaturalNews) The mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccines were not developed, manufactured, or distributed under traditional regulatory frameworks that govern drug approval in…
The crazed Democrats and lunatic Liberals tried to wreck Americaâs children and ruin their lives, so hereâs how to fix their moral compass
(NaturalNews) Have the crazy, perved-out Liberals warped your childâs mind and body over the past 4 years? From social media to Hollywood and Disney, itâs tough…
U.K. Met Office under fire for fabricating temperature data from non-existent stations
(NaturalNews) On August 26, the U.K. Met Office, Britainâs official meteorological service, found itself at the center of a scandal after evidence emerged suggest…
What happens when America kills its Christian soul
Is the idea of a Christian nation the definition of “absolute absurdity”? According to one Christian magazine, the answer is yes.
Earlier this month, the supposedly thoughtful Plough magazine published a breathtaking exercise in intellectual cowardice, dismissing the very foundation of Western civilization as “absolute absurdity.” The essay in question tackles the subject of Christian nationhood, but it reads like a surrender document, abandoning two millennia of proven governance for faddish defeatism.
To deny the role of Christian truth in Western greatness is like denying oxygen’s role in breathing.
What lunacy drives this thinking?
The greatest civilizations in human history — medieval England’s common law, America’s founding principles, Wilberforce’s abolition movement — all emerged from Christian bedrock. These weren’t theocratic nightmares but flourishing societies that elevated human dignity precisely because they recognized divine authority above earthly empires.
History is a series of patterns, and one of them keeps repeating in America.
Forged in faith
In the 1700s, the colonies rose against the monarchy not for the sake of godless liberty, but because they believed their rights were God-given, written into creation itself. Sermons rang from meeting-houses declaring that no king could overrule the King of kings.
In the 1800s, churches formed the backbone of abolition and reform. Preachers thundered that slavery was a sin before heaven. Abolitionists carried Bibles alongside petitions. And hymns like “Amazing Grace” became anthems of emancipation.
Their message was simple: Every man was equal because every soul bore the image of God.
In the 1900s, Martin Luther King Jr. stood in that same tradition, speaking from pulpits with scripture as his shield. His call for justice was never detached from his faith. He quoted Amos and Isaiah as readily as the founders, grounding civil rights in the authority of the Almighty.
Every advance in American freedom came wrapped in Christian conviction.
Wings, not shackles
But today we’re told these foundations are obsolete, that “Christian nation” is a dirty phrase, and that the values that guided our forefathers must be disavowed like toxic waste. The elites sneer that faith in the public square is “exclusionary,” as if the alternative — soulless secularism — has produced anything but despair, drugs, gender-bending, and fractured families.
But the truth couldn’t be any clearer.
Christian ideals were never shackles; they’re wings. Justice tempered by mercy. Individual worth regardless of station. Care for the vulnerable, not because it wins votes, but because it reflects the imago Dei. Moral accountability to a higher law that no king, no president, and no bureaucrat can erase.
RELATED: The left’s new anti-Christian smear backfires — exposing its deepest fear
jokerpro/iStock/Getty Images Plus
These principles are humanity’s highest aspirations. They built cathedrals that still tower when kingdoms fall. They gave birth to parliaments instead of pogroms, hospitals instead of hangings, and constitutions instead of cults. The entire Western canon — from Augustine’s “City of God” to Aquinas’ natural law, from Magna Carta to the Bill of Rights — rests on this sacred scaffolding.
Every liberty we prize today was planted in soil first tilled by faith.
Secularism’s harvest
This is what the Plough party misses. If America forsakes its Christian roots, it doesn’t drift into neutrality. It falls into the hands of new lawgivers, those who craft commandments for commerce — not for conscience.
Already we see this counterfeit creed: Banks cancel customers for thought crimes, corporations peddle ESG as ersatz salvation, Silicon Valley preaches virtue while addicting children and dismantling families, algorithms determine who can speak, credit scores determine who can buy, bureaucrats determine whose children are taught what is right and what is wrong.
From there, the descent is undeniable. When a boy is told he can become a girl by fiat, when schools scrub scripture but sanctify drag shows, when fentanyl fells more Americans than any war ever fought — this is the harvest of secular rule. A culture that once exalted discipline and faith now exalts indulgence and self-invention, producing generations unmoored, medicated, and utterly miserable.
Of course, critics will raise straw men.
“Do you want to stone adulterers?”Is this an attempt to ban other religions?””Are you trying to enforce Levitical law?”
No serious Christian makes such claims. The point isn’t theocracy. It’s renewal.
The true absurdity
A society shaped by Christian morality has always been freer than one governed by the cold calculus of power. The founders knew it. John Adams said it plainly, “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious People. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”
Remove the moral compass, and the machinery of liberty grinds into tyranny. Without Christian restraint, power consolidates, rights vanish, and man becomes a cog in someone else’s machine.
Plough may shrug and call that “absolute absurdity.” But the absurdity is Plough’s.
To deny the role of Christian truth in Western greatness is like denying oxygen’s role in breathing. We can’t cut out the heart and expect the body to live. Every triumph of the West was animated by Christian conviction. To sneer at that inheritance is to sneer at the very civilization that grants these critics the freedom to sneer in the first place.
The blood of martyrs and the ink of reformers didn’t flow so we could trade a living faith for lifeless ideologies that serve only the state and the market.
America’s survival depends not on importing ideologies from Davos or Silicon Valley, but on returning to the well that never runs dry.
Plough magazine, Christian nationhood, Christianity, Jesus, God, Bible, Jesus christ, Christian, Christian nation, Faith
Trump Says Trilateral Ukraine Summit Still on the Cards
President Trump believes a trilateral meeting between the US, Russia and Ukraine is still on the cards as he continues to seek an end to [more…]
Lawsuit: ChatGPT Encouraged Teen To Plan a “Beautiful Suicide”
ChatGPT encouraged a teen who killed himself to plan a “beautiful suicide” and even offered to draft his suicide note, a new lawsuit alleges
British Government Giving Out Special “Global Talent” Visas to Foreign Drag Queens
The British government is handing out special visas for “global talent” to foreign drag queens, a Daily Telegraph investigation has revealed
A statue tests America’s fading demand for assimilation
In Sugar Land, Texas, a giant statue depicting the monkey-faced Hindu deity Hanuman was erected in August 2024. Officially titled “Statue of Union,” many Texans and Americans elsewhere have found this monument to be an aberration. For some, it is the aesthetic unsightliness. For others, it is a religious aversion to having a pagan idol being raised to such heights. And for others, it is a demonstration of just how many foreigners now live in Texas.
I see each of these points as pins on a board that, when connected, reveal a fault line in American civic life: We are divided culturally — and the divide is widening.
If citizenship is only a piece of paper that protects you from deportation and allows you access to our material goods and services, then we have devalued it to the point of being worthless.
America is not an abstract, universal idea that anyone can adopt, as a former Obama-appointed global citizen opined recently in his chiding of Vice President JD Vance’s speech at the Claremont Institute’s Statesmanship Award dinner this summer. America requires Americans. No, we don’t all need to look and sound identical, but we do need to be specific about what makes an American an American.
American culture, with its Christian civil religion, is required to maintain this union of states and their self-governing peoples. You cannot take people from any other civic, commercial, or cultural context, drop them within American borders, and expect that you will get the same results as from those who are fully assimilated to our country’s historic way of life.
Indians are from an old civilization that is distinct from the one built in Europe, globalized by Britain and Spain, that America currently is an inheritor and torchbearer of. While many Indians have successfully adopted the Western way of life, many more carry an apprehension toward American culture.
Many of the Hindu Indians I live around in the suburbs north of Dallas will freely admit that they moved here merely for higher-paying jobs and the availability of nice things they were unable to obtain in India. “We had a farm. I was happy. But my son wanted a better job,” one sweet matron told my wife with a resigned sadness. “My family is here, so I must be here.” Another has remarked how she loves to sit at her window and watch my six children playing outside, as she only has one grandchild who has been raised in America — and her children want no more, as it would interfere with their work.
I feel a certain sympathy with these immigrants who are struggling with culture shock. They may have nicer homes in America — but they are not at home. This is a strange land to them, just as India would be to me if I lived there. And the American is a stranger to them. They do not consider themselves Americans, and they are worried that their children and descendants will become like the strangers they live among.
The Sugar Land statue, or “murti,” along with other religious displays such as celebrations of Diwali, are not simple public practices of faith; they are cultural statements meant to pacify fears among Hindus that their native culture and its religion will be lost to America’s material excesses and its Christian religion. Large numbers of Hindu Indians living in proximity to each other enable them to speak their native language, eat their traditional foods, and practice their religion.
In essence, Indian culture is kept intact, and Indians remain insulated from and unassimilated to American culture. Many do not become American — they remain Indians who just happen to live in America.
RELATED: How woke broke the country
Photo by Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
I regret that I must use Indian immigrants as my example of unassimilated America. They are merely responding to what has become commonplace in America, England, Canada, and the West more broadly — and therefore what they believe to be the norm.
English is unwritten and unspoken in increasing numbers of our cities and towns, with residents unable to speak our nation’s language and being offered the choice to vote for a foreign-born Marxist in New York City. Dueling demonstrations carrying Palestinian and Israeli flags have become almost commonplace in our streets, just as residents of California wave Mexican flags in protest of their forthcoming deportations.
Somalis in Minnesota celebrate their native country’s independence day en masse together with local officials — then vote them out in favor of alternatives they consider their own. When I asked one recently naturalized immigrant from Colombia if she considered herself an American now that she is a citizen, she said bluntly, “No. I am Colombian.”
What would have been thought of as egregious foreign incursions a hundred years ago is the message America now sends: Becoming an American is not akin to living in America or being a citizen of America. It is completely optional. If citizenship is only a piece of paper that protects you from deportation and allows you access to our material goods and services, then we have devalued it to the point of being worthless.
No hyphenated Americans
When thinking of small ethno-religious minorities in America like Hassidic Jews (180,000) or the Amish (395,000) who have historically kept mostly to themselves, this point may seem trite. But it is consequential when the sheer number of Hindus — and the potential for many, many more — is truly understood.
The last U.S. census posits that over 450,000 Hindus reside in Texas alone, doubled from a decade ago. In 2022, Indians composed the largest share of international homebuyers in Central Texas, according to an Austin Board of Realtors report. Texas Governor Greg Abbott (R) has gone to India twice on diplomatic missions, touting mutually beneficial financial arrangements and “common values of family, faith, compassion, and hard work.”
Economics aside, these are supposed cultural values that the governor is identifying. While all the words Governor Abbott used are perhaps debatable, the biggest equivocation is “faith.” Quite obviously in contradiction to the governor, the historic faith of Texans, Christianity, is not held in common with the vast majority of Indians, who are Hindu.
Though I have no flat objection to the arrival of specific individuals from elsewhere in the world who wish to become unhyphenated Americans in order to better themselves and the United States, the construction of a foreign idol by a rapidly expanding minority population of newcomers underscores the loss of what used to be a requirement to live in America: assimilation into its culture, of which its civil religion — Christianity — is a cornerstone.
In a post for the Institute of Religion and Democracy’s blog “Juicy Ecumenism,” Mark Tooley rebuked me and others for expressing the desire for a shared American culture and dismay at literal pagan idols being raised in our homeland. Tooley asks what “Christian nationalists” (a label I’ve rejected as an inaccurate pejorative used by militant anti-Christians) think the government should do in this matter?
We can debate specific proposals, but my wish is for those in government and our nation’s institutions to be conscious of the part a homogenous culture plays in a stable, civilized society. The thought that “government might do something!” to curate or protect the dominant and preferred culture of its historic people is apparently beyond the comprehension of some. So to help fire the imagination, let us look at another people who came to America — and to Texas: the German people.
German assimilation
In his book, “Turning Germans into Texans: World War I and the Assimilation and Survival of German Culture in Texas, 1900-1930,” Matthew D. Tippens offers an instructive case study in assimilation and the formation of civic identity. He traces the journey of German immigrants who arrived in Texas in the mid-19th century, with their own language, customs, religion, and ethos.
Lutheran, Catholic, or freethinking, these settlers had formed a broad but still insular group, slow to integrate into the already established fabric of American and regional Texan life. Tippens’ narrative is sympathetic (as am I) to the losses of ethnic distinctiveness, but it provides a compelling portrait of how cultural assimilation, often aided by state policy, forged a cohesive national character.
A nation’s people and their governing bodies have both the right and the duty to demand that newcomers conform to the nation’s cultural and religious norms.
Germans in Texas preserved their linguistic and institutional separateness into the 20th century. They published German-language newspapers, conducted German-speaking services in German churches, maintained German schools that taught in the German tongue, and established community halls and festivals that reinforced their communal boundaries. Tippens documents this with care, noting how these practices kept the “German-Texan” identity distinct from the “Anglo-Texan” majority. But the arrival of World War I marked a decisive rupture.
Amid rising national insecurity over split loyalties among the public, the government of the state of Texas, and in some cases the federal government in Washington, moved swiftly to eliminate internal doubts. The German language was prohibited in public schools. Pastors were pressured to preach in English. Local officials even began treating private speech in German as potentially seditious. In short, the state, backed by public sentiment, enforced a program of assimilation with remarkable efficiency. Tippens, while critical of its harshness, acknowledges its efficacy: Within a generation, German cultural institutions in Texas collapsed.
But the German people did not. They endured — not as a separate ethnos, but as Americans. They married across ethnic lines, adapted to prevailing civic norms, and ceased to think of themselves as Germans first. In place of a hyphenated identity, they adopted a national one.
RELATED: ‘Paperwork Americans’ are not your countrymen
Blaze Media Illustration
This transformation of Germans into Americans may have been jarring while it was taking place, but it stands as a triumph of political formation and moral cohesion. It demonstrated that assimilation is not merely possible, but necessary, and that cultural inheritance need not be lost in the midst of it — it can be transformed and incorporated into a higher unity.
Tippens and some Americans of German descent still feel a sense of sadness over the loss of their distinct traditions and language inherited from the old country — but not a single one would prefer to go back to Europe or transform America into Germany. They are Americans. Not German-Americans. Just Americans. America is their home. And they love it. Though they may hold aspects of their peculiar subculture near and dear in food, songs, and stories, they have submitted that culture to this land’s particular culture, the American culture.
Is the history of this forced assimilation a tragedy? Perhaps, to a degree. But it was politically and morally justified. And those who care for national unity should view it as a welcome precedent.
A nation’s people and their governing bodies have both the right and the duty to demand that newcomers conform to the nation’s cultural and religious norms. Without a shared group identity, no nation can survive. The American nation, particularly in moments of strain, has always exercised this prerogative. It was this principled assertiveness that transformed a continent of European colonists and later immigrants into a single people.
In our present moment, we have reversed that logic. To insist that immigrants adopt our language, mores, and civic ideals is now seen not as patriotic, but as prejudicial. Not only do we not hold recent immigrants to this standard, but we’ve reversed course on historical minorities who were on their way to full assimilation by decrying “whiteness” (another word for American cultural norms) as something that should be scorned, rejected, and outright rebelled against — the invisible hand of bigotry and oppression we all must condemn without reservation. You could say, “It is not enough to not be an American; you must be anti-American.”
Without a unifying identity — what makes the “pluribus” an “unum” — pluralism will rapidly dissolve into tribalism. Americans less than a hundred years ago understood this. Why should we play dumb now?
Refusing to worship the ideal of another
The present-day case of Sugar Land, Texas, where a towering Hindu idol has been erected, should be unacceptable to Americans (especially Christians), and doubly so to those of Indian heritage who see this land as their own and this people as their people.
Unlike a German store or Lutheran school of the 19th century, which could be and were quickly subordinated to American norms, a monument to a god from a distinctly foreign civilization proclaims a parallel order that makes no pretense of assimilation. It is not a gesture of integration, but of presence — and an intention of permanence. This goes for any statue, temple, campus, mural, or other declarations of occupation.
What you elevate in the public eye is what you encourage the people to idealize in their hearts. Do we want immigrants to be looking backward at what they left? Or looking forward to what they now are privileged to inherit?
Tooley says this is simply the cost of pluralism. But pluralism is not an end in itself. It is the fruit of a Christian order that’s confident enough to tolerate minority views, because it assumes its own cultural hegemony. If that majority is disregarded and that confidence eroded, pluralism becomes its opposite: a Babel of conflicting gods and moralities, doomed to be abandoned and fall.
Without a shared group identity, no nation can survive.
No one is advocating deliberate government persecution of American citizens who observe certain religious tenets or have recent ancestors from foreign nations. The First Amendment guarantees religious liberty. But let’s be honest about our founders’ intentions: The purpose of that liberty was to protect dissenting Christian sects within a Christian moral framework — not to permit the importation of rival civilizational orders.
The crux of the issue is not that there exists private practice of Hinduism in some form, or even simply that an offensive statue to one of the Hindu deities stands against the Texas sky. The statue itself is a public manifestation of an under-examined reality: that unassimilated cultures exist in America.
Beyond that, it is a declaration of intent to remain unassimilated. For the idol to be excused and dismissed shows a resignation to this reality and a toleration for this intention — and it is this nihilism that is unprecedented in our history and fundamentally un-American, not my protestations or the protestations of anyone who would refuse to bow to it.
RELATED: New immigrants struggle to assimilate — and we all pay for it
Photo by Irfan Khan/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images
As Kevin D. Williamson recently noted, America is a Christian nation not by legal fiat but by cultural fact — just as it is an English-speaking nation without a statute requiring it. Christianity shaped our institutions, our conception of law and liberty, our ethos of charity, and our traditions of self-rule. The civic peace that Tooley praises is not sustained by diversity for the sake of itself, but by the cultural cohesion that Christian norms and people who valued that culture once ensured.
The deeper question, then, is not whether non-Christian Americans have a right to worship, or if immigrants can hold to elements of their historic culture, but whether Americans retain the right to shape their own nation’s future. Are we permitted to determine whether the foundation we build upon remains a distinctly Western, Christian civilization that assimilates outsiders into its mold? Or is becoming a polyglot holding pen for mutually exclusive, competing cultures the only acceptable answer?
This land is our land
Germans were made into Americans not because they were coerced by mobs. The government prevented such unrest by heeding the concerns of the citizenry. By understanding the requirements of cohesion and acting decisively to incentivize the transformation, America avoided the dangers of sectarian strife when international affairs came to the forefront.
Through intentional public policy and community expression of displeasure, clear expectations were conveyed that immigrants were required to become Americans. And the Germans, to their credit, responded. They quite rapidly entered the civic mainstream after years of delay.
If the United States of America is to endure, we must raise our expectations for citizenship, which is a precious thing.
What we face now is more intractable. The newest arrivals — not only Indians but many others as well — are coming in greater numbers than any prior groups and do not believe they need to change for America. To the contrary, America must change for them.
They establish communities that replicate the political and cultural norms of their homelands. They vote as blocs. They see the issues of their native countries as taking pre-eminence over their present states. And they raise monuments to foreign gods — not in private devotion, but in public affirmation of the lands, lives, and loyalties they were supposed to have left behind.
This is not assimilation. It is colonization. And it is too often encouraged by Americans who have lost the sense of what this country is and ought to be. In an insipid diatribe railing against Vance and the pro-American tone of the government, a blogger for the Los Angeles Times wrote, “I learned in high school that people come here not because of how Americans live, but because they have the freedom to live however they want.” He speaks truthfully, as this lie is taught in our education system and preached by formerly elite institutions. The message is loud and clear: Come to America, live in America — but do not become an American.
If a distinctly American identity undergirded by a Christian civilization is no longer asserted, what shall replace it? A thousand shrines? A hundred languages? No common law, no common culture, no shared moral grammar?
Is this what you want for America? Perhaps you do, or you do not care. But for those of us who love it, we want an America that holds to its roots and maintains our constitutional order and our civilization. To do so, we must not shy away from reasserting a distinctly American identity and setting the conditions for acceptance into its culture, not just our borders.
Regaining the ‘Leitkultur’
Pluralism rests on the center trunk of a dominant culture, a Leitkultur, not the absence of one. Subcultures can be preserved when there is a monoculture that all can live in accordance with.
We must find again the will to expect — not merely invite — assimilation from any and all who wish to call this land their home. And we must recognize that the choice before us is not a specter of the “Christian nationalism” of secularist smear campaigns versus perfect tolerance, but a distinctly American nation built on a Christian civilization versus fractious, tribal chaos.
If the United States of America is to endure as one indivisible nation under God, we must take these signs seriously and raise our expectations for citizenship, which is a precious thing. It should not be portrayed as just a piece of paper awarded for correctly answering multiple-choice questions on a test and meeting some material preconditions. It must resolve the question of loyalty. It must involve a pledge of allegiance to the republic. For it is a sacred oath that symbolizes the bond with your fellow citizens.
It is as a baptism, where the old man and his old loyalties to his old nation and its old laws, his old people, and their old gods die with him. But a new, better man rises. One who gives loyalty to a better nation, with better laws, a better people, and a better God.
Editor’s note: This article was published originally at the American Mind.
Opinion & analysis, Opinion, Hanuman statue, Assimilation, Immigration, Citizenship, Texas, Naturalization, Duty, English, Hindu, Sugar land, Religion, Culture, Nationalism
Chicago Mayor Moves To Block Deployment of National Guard to City
Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson has signed an executive order aimed at preventing the Trump administration from deploying the military to the city.
Over 500 Attacks on Catholic Churches in US Since 2020
Since 2020 there have been over 500 attacks on Catholic churches in the US, including the deadly attack on Annunciation Catholic Church in Minneapolis, when [more…]
Trump: I’ll Issue Executive Order Requiring Voter IDs
“Voter I.D. Must Be Part of Every Single Vote. NO EXCEPTIONS!” President Trump wrote in a post on Truth Social
